HTR vol. 64 #2-3 |
Kleine Beitrage zur Siedlungsgeschichte der Stamme Asser und Juda |
Kuschke, Arnulf |
April-July 1971 |
German article that mentions an x2x handle excavated from "Eswa'" (Estaol; includes handle drawing) |
HTR vol. 64 #2-3 |
Royal Stamps & the Kingdom of Josiah, The |
Lance, H. Darrell |
April-July 1971 |
An excellent analysis of the LMLK handles excavated from Gibeon, Ramat Rahel, Lachish (the bulk of the discussion), Gezer, & Jerusalem concluding in support of King Josiah's usage over King Hezekiah's by believing Lachish 3 was not destroyed by Sennacherib (18 pages) |
HTR vol. 72 #1-2 |
Hezekiah's Reform & the Deuteronomistic Tradition |
Rosenbaum, Jonathan |
January-April 1979 |
Article that includes a page about LMLK theories explaining that Hezekiah's dominion was superior to Josiah's irrespective of any theory |
'I Will Speak the Riddles of Ancient Times': Archaeological & Historical Studies in Honor of Amihai Mazar on the Occasion of His Sixtieth Birthday vol. 2 |
Function of the m(w)sh-Stamped Jars Revisited, The |
Edelman, Diana & Maeir, A. M. & de Miroschedji, P. |
2006 |
Mostly reviews Mozah theories in the Babylonian rather than Persian period, & draws some parallels to LMLKs (13 pages overall, but only about 2 with specific LMLK content) |
'I Will Speak the Riddles of Ancient Times': Archaeological & Historical Studies in Honor of Amihai Mazar on the Occasion of His Sixtieth Birthday vol. 2 |
lmlk Jar-Form Redefined: A New Class of Iron Age II Oval-Shaped Storage Jar, The |
Gitin, Seymour & Maeir, A. M. & de Miroschedji, P. |
2006 |
Proposes a new classification system combining LMLKs & Rosettes, stamped & unstamped, 4- & 2-handled jars spanning 2 centuries (17 pages, small drawings of 3 LMLK-stamped jars) |
IEJ vol. 3 #2 |
Another bat-le-melekh Inscription |
Avigad, N. |
1953 |
Proposes a new interpretation of a sherd from Nasbeh based on the BT LMLK found at Lachish (2 pages, 1 photo, 1 drawing) |
IEJ vol. 6 #3 |
Excavations at Ramath Rahel, 1954 |
Aharoni, Y. |
1956 |
Briefly mentions the first 2 handles (x2xR & Z2D) found in the first season along with their photos |
IEJ vol. 8 #1 |
Negeb of Judah, The |
Aharoni, Y. |
1958 |
Photos of an x4L & handles with Plus Marks from Tell 'Ira (Khirbat al-Gharra); no significant text |
IEJ vol. 8 #2 |
New Light on the MSH Seal Impressions |
Avigad, N. |
1958 |
Argues for the association of MSH with Mosah instead of Mizpah & includes a page of text drawing an analogy to the interpretation of MMST as an abbreviation for MMSLT |
IEJ vol. 14 #3 |
Excavations at Tel Arad: Preliminary Report on the First Season, 1962 |
Aharoni, Y. & Amiran, Ruth |
1964 |
Photo of an S4L handle & a paragraph of text mentioning 4 others |
IEJ vol. 18 #4 |
Jar Inscriptions from Shiqmona |
Cross Jr., F.M. |
1968 |
Presents drawings of 2 Persian-era, Phoenician-cursive, ink-written ostraca ("Ben Matton, 25 LMLK wine of Gat Karmel") with a brief comparison to the LMLK seals (8 pages including a paleography chart) |
IEJ vol. 20 #3-4 |
Excavations in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem, 1970 (2nd Preliminary Report) |
Avigad, N. |
1970 |
Includes a photo of an H2D handle; no significant text |
IEJ vol. 20 #3-4 |
Review of P. Welten's "Die Konigs-Stempel" |
Aharoni, Y. |
1970 |
While complimenting the exhaustive content, Aharoni criticizes Welten's division of 2-winged icons & contradictory interpretation of archaeological reports--especially relating to Josiah's reign (2 pages) |
IEJ vol. 34 #2-3 |
Provenience of the LMLK Jars, The |
Mommsen, H. & Perlman, I. & Yellin, J. |
1984 |
Provides an excellent, comprehensive LMLK summary along with detailed chemical analysis of LMLK-related pottery from over 100 handles (including Type 484 jars with all seal types, pithoi, & several complete jars) drawing the conclusion that all Type 484 jars were made from clays which are indistinguishable (25 pages including 8 tables) |
IEJ vol. 39 #1-2 |
LMLK Stamp from Beth-El, A |
Eshel, Hanan |
1989 |
Presents alternative interpretations of sparse LMLK handles found beyond Judah's borders (3 pages plus photo & drawing of an x4L) |
IEJ vol. 40 #4 |
Two Hebrew 'Fiscal' Bullae |
Avigad, N. |
1990 |
Detailed presentation/analysis of the Eltolad LMLK bulla (4 pages, front & profile photos) |
IEJ vol. 45 #1 |
King of Babylonia or a Judaean Official?, The |
Barkay, Gabriel |
1995 |
Presents 5 major reasons for interpreting the LMRA seal as a LMLK personal seal instead of a later period seal representing a king or governor (6 pages, 2 photos, 1 drawing) |
IEJ vol. 45 #4 |
Rosette Stamp Seal Impressions from Ancient Judah |
Cahill, Jane M. |
1995 |
The landmark study of jars resembling Type 484 including a comprehensive classification system & frequent comparisons to LMLK jars (23 pages including 15 photos showing 12 rosette handles & 2 rosette jars, drawings of handle cross-sections, corpus chart, distribution map, & stratification table) |
IEJ vol. 54 #2 |
Rosette-stamped Handles: Instrumental Neutron Activation Analysis |
Yellin, Joseph & Cahill, Jane M. |
2004 |
Provides results of a chemical analysis of Rosette handles, & compares them to LMLK Type 484 handles & LMLK pithoi (21 pages including 4 tables & 2 graphs) |
Im Schatten Deiner Flugel |
|
Keel, Othmar & Staubli, Thomas |
2001 |
German book that suggests the scarab icon on LMLK seals represents YHWH as the God of Jerusalem with a presentation of Christian dove art implying a continuity of iconographic tradition (color photo of H4C & S4L handles) |
Inscribed Seals from First Temple |
|
Hestrin, Ruth & Dayagi-Mendels, Michal |
1978 |
Hebrew book with photo of H2D handle with #687-22a personal seal |
Inscriptions Reveal |
|
Carmon, Efrat & Hestrin, Ruth |
1973 (2nd ed.; English translation by R. Grafman) |
Includes a page of discussion written in Hebrew & English with photos of Jar 60-501 & handles with H2D (with #687-22a personal seal), H2U, H4L, M2D, S4L, & Z2D impressions along with many other artifacts & an excellent paleography chart |
Interpreter's Dictionary of the Bible, The |
Seals & Scarabs |
Tufnell, O. & Buttrick, George Arthur |
1962 |
Brief summary of royal symbols & stamps used by wine exporters (H4C, H4L, & H2U stamp photos) |
Investigations at Lachish: The Sanctuary & the Residency (Lachish V) |
|
Aharoni, Yohanan |
1975 |
One page of text describing 15 impressions (1 plate of 15 photos) |
Iscrizioni Antico-Ebraiche Palestinesi, Le |
|
Diringer, David |
Dec 1934 |
Italian book with a comprehensive chapter on LMLK seals & the Gezer weight with an extensive bibliography (16 pages; photo of 1 H4L & 2 S2U plus 21 crude drawings based on other drawings) |
Israel in Antiquity |
|
Jewish Museum (New York), The |
1982 |
A page of general overview along with photos of an H4L & H2U from Lachish |
Israel Philatelist vol. 34 #1/2, The |
Nature & Origin of the Flying Scroll Design |
Farber, William D. |
February 1983 |
Provides background details on how the 2-winged LMLK seal design was chosen for Israel's first postage stamps in 1948 (7 pages; photos of Jar 5461 & H2U handle; drawings of Z4CI, S4L, & S2U stamps; Aharoni's 12 Judean Districts map) |
Israel Philatelist vol. 57 #3, The |
Part 1 (Flying Scroll) Digging Deeper into the 1948 Festival Stamps |
Grena, G.M. |
June 2006 |
Archaeological update for Israel's first postage stamps in 1948 with an emphasis on the original design (4 pages; Z2U illustration & its matching impression photo; color photo of 2 Z2U handles from the Redondo Beach collection) |
Israel Pocket Library: Archaeology |
|
Avi-Yonah, Michael |
1974 |
Compiled from material originally published in the Encyclopaedia Judaica; no editor/author, but Avi-Yonah wrote the book's intro. & co-authored the Hebron section, which includes an H4L photo |
JBS issue 1:2 |
Reading Religious Artifacts: The Shrine Room at Judahite Tell Halif |
Jacobs, Paul |
Apr/Jun 2001 |
Provides details about 2 restored "lamelek type" storage jars |
Jericho: Die Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen |
|
Sellin, Ernst & Watzinger, Carl |
1913 |
German book with a paragraph of description & photo of an S2DR handle |
Jerusalem Archaeological Park, The |
|
Reich, Ronny & Avni, Gideon & Winter, Tamar |
1999 |
Guidebook for tourists to excavation sites around Jerusalem (no significant text, but includes 1911 M2T drawing) |
Jerusalem: Excavating 3000 Years of History |
|
Kenyon, Kathleen M. |
1967 |
Only 2 photos of handles (S2U & H4L) from Lachish with a paragraph of description |
Jewish Encyclopedia vol. 10 Philipson-Samoscz, The |
Pottery |
Singer, Isidore & Hirsch, Emil G. & Bliss, Frederick J. |
1905 |
Description of Jewish Period stamps that compares the theories of Bliss & Macalister--Royal Potteries vs. District Centers, respectively (1 page of text with H4L stamp & handle drawings) |
Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem Conducted by Nahman Avigad, 1969-1982: Vol. I |
|
Geva, Hillel & Avigad, Nahman & Barkay, Gabriel |
2000 |
Description of Areas A, W, & X-2 stratigraphy with an excellent overview chapter on LMLK & related seal impressions including circle incisions (11 pages of text, photos of 42 impressions, & corpus chart that introduces an axis orientation system) |
JNES vol. 10 #4 |
Two Hebrew Ostraca from Tell Qasile |
Maisler, B. |
October 1951 |
Presents a LMLK ostracon (1 photo & 1 page of text--the other ostracon was written by a different person about Ophir gold for Beth Huron & does not include the word LMLK) |
Journal Asiatique ser. 8 vol. 1 |
Sceaux et Cachets |
Clermont-Ganneau, M. Charles |
Feb/Mar 1883 |
French article that analyzes 6 of Warren's original handles, refutes the theory that they name kings or offerings to the pagan deity, & proposes that they name potters (2 pages) |
Journal for Semitics vol. 15 #2 |
Seals of Jezebel & Other Women in Authority |
Korpel, Marjo C.A. |
2006 |
Analyzes an unprovenanced personal seal inscribed "YZBL" with Egyptian icons (photos of an H2D & S4L; only 1 page of LMLK content, but footnote 36 on p. 361 is the first reference to this website in a formal scientific publication) |
Journal of Epigraphy & Rock Drawings, Third Issue |
Arabian Seals and Bullae Along the Trade Routes of Judah and Edom |
van der Veen, Pieter Gert |
2009 |
Defends "LNRT" reading of LMRA impression (2 pages; includes photo of plasticine impression) |
Journal of Hebrew Scriptures vol. 12, article 4 |
Archaeological Facts, Historical Speculations & the Date of the LMLK Storage Jars: A Rejoinder to David Ussishkin |
Lipschits, Oded |
March 2012 |
(published online; click here to read it) |
Journal of the Palestine Oriental Society vol. 5 |
Administrative Divisions of Israel & Judah, The |
Albright, W.F. |
1925 |
Discusses the identification of districts throughout the 12 tribes & uses the LMLK inscriptions to illustrate their evolution, but also summarizes all of the LMLK theories up to that time (37 pages total including 2 map drawings--10 have LMLK content) |
Judah & Jerusalem |
Negev (South) of Judah, The |
Aharoni, Y. (no editor named) |
1957 |
Hebrew chapter with photo of an x4L from Tell 'Ira (Khirbat al-Gharra); published in English in IEJ vol. 8 #1 |
Kedem: Studies in Jewish Archaeology |
Meaning of the "Le-Melekh" Inscriptions, The |
Sukenik, E.L. |
1942 |
5-page Hebrew chapter that argues for the royal standard measure theory with a good photo of Jar 5461 & BT LMLK fragment |
Khirbet Nisyah: The Search for Biblical Ai, 1979-2002 |
|
Livingston, David |
2003 |
Excavation report including an x2x handle photo with interesting correspondence between the author/excavator & Albright & Kelso over the locations of Bethel & Ai |
Khirbet Qumran et Ain Feshkha II |
|
Humbert, Jean-Baptiste & Gunneweg, Jan & Lemaire, Andre |
2003 |
French excavation report including a G2T photo |
Kingdom of Hezekiah: Judah in the Geo-Political Context of the Late Eighth Century BCE, The |
|
Hooker, Paul Kenneth |
1993 |
Uses LMLK evidence beginning with "Die Konigs-Stempel" to support an analysis of Hezekiah's reign (about 20 pages) |
Konigs-Stempel, Die |
|
Welten, Peter |
1969 |
German book ("The King's Stamp") with more content about LMLK impressions than any other published work (including paleography charts, a detailed corpus, & sketched maps showing site locations for each city name; 204 pages but no photos) |
Lachish III (Tell ed-Duweir): The Iron Age (Plates) |
|
Tufnell, Olga |
1953 |
Contains three photos of two restored Type 484 jars (5400 & 5461), the Bath LMLK Jar, & a plate of 31 impressions (same ones published by Diringer in PEQ July 1941) |
Lachish III (Tell ed-Duweir): The Iron Age (Text) |
|
Tufnell, Olga & Diringer, David |
1953 |
About 6 pages of text with descriptions of Type 484 jars & loci/context of excavated handles, arguments for class 1 = early 8th, class 2 = late 8th, class 3 =7th centuries, & comments regarding the Bath LMLK Jar plus paleography & corpus charts (310 for Lachish & 492 total up to that time) |
Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography, The |
|
Aharoni, Yohanan |
1967 (English edition translated by A.F. Rainey) |
Provides many maps (such as fortresses & districts) covering the history of Palestine plus 6 pages about the LMLK mystery with an emphasis on their geographical-administrative significance while arguing for their usage being restricted to Hezekiah/Manasseh |
Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography, The (Revised & Enlarged Edition) |
|
Aharoni, Yohanan |
1979 (English edition translated by A.F. Rainey) |
Minor modifications to the original edition (1962 Hebrew, 1967 English), especially to the "Districts of Judah" map, the paragraph about Lachish handles, & to the last page of LMLK text summarizing the purpose (still 6 relevant pages) |
Law & Ideology in Monarchic Israel |
Jerusalem & the Lineages in the Seventh Century BCE: Kinship & the Rise of Individual Moral Liability |
Halpern, Baruch |
1991 |
A 2-page discussion of the military build-up theory |
Like a Bird in a Cage |
|
Grabbe, Lester L. |
2003 |
Presentations by multiple authors at a 2000 seminar discussing various aspects related to Sennacherib's attack of Judah, but Grabbe's introduction rehearses important LMLK corpora (15 pages of text) |
Lion Encyclopedia of the Bible, The |
|
Alexander, Pat & Millard, Alan & Parish, Stephen |
1978 |
Includes one paragraph about the stamps & a page describing ancient pottery manufacture (color M2D photo) |
LMLK--A Mystery Belonging to the King vol. 1 |
|
Grena, G.M. |
April 2004 |
Click here to preview the contents |
LMLK Blogspot |
Intact Jars--Watch Your Mouths! |
Grena, G.M. |
June 3-7 2006 |
(published online; click here to read it) |
LRW |
LMLK Seals in the Michael Welch Collection |
Welch, Michael |
March 2003 |
(published online; click here to read it) |
Mambre |
|
Mader, Evaristus |
1957 |
German book with a page that provides a general overview & mentions 2 H4x handles found at Keilah |
Messages from the Past |
|
Deutsch, Robert |
1999 (English edition) |
Contains photos, drawings, & descriptions of Hebrew bullae from the time of Isaiah to the destruction of Solomon's temple, including 3 with "LMLK" inscribed on them) |
LRW |
Michael Welch's Review of "LMLK--A Mystery Belonging to the King vol. 1" |
Welch, Michael |
June 2004 |
(published online; click here to read it) |
Ministry vol. 64 #7 |
Jar Handles Reveal Hezekiah's Hopes |
Younker, Randall W. |
July 1991 |
Concentrates on the expansion of Jerusalem during Hezekiah's reign due to immigration following the fall of Samaria & tends to agree with Tushingham's proposal that the 2 icons represent Judah & Israel; prefers the military supplies theory but doesn't attempt to explain the 4 words (4 pages, photos of M2D #3464 & M4C #5943-1 from "Discovering Jerusalem") |
Modern Research as Illustrating the Bible |
|
Driver, S.R. |
1909 |
Summary of evidence & theories (3 pages of text, 1 page of 15 impression drawings borrowed from "Excavations in Palestine") |
Monographs of the Hebrew Union College #23 |
In the Service of the King: Officialdom in Ancient Israel & Judah |
Fox, Nili Sacher |
2000 |
Minor revision of her 1997 dissertation entitled "Royal Functionaries..." (20 pages in this format) |
NEASB vol. 46 |
Judean Jar Handles Bearing Concentric Circles |
Ji, Chang-Ho |
2001 |
Examination of handles with Circle marks that suggests they were made during Manasseh's reign (11 pages; drawings of S2DW, M2D, x2x; photos of H2U & H4L from Lachish & x2x with Circles at Horn Archaeological Museum) |
NEASB vol. 55 |
LMLK Storage Jars & the Reign of Uzziah: Towards a Mid-eighth Century B.C. Terminus a Quo for the Royal Jars of the Kingdom of Judah, The |
Hudon, Jeffrey P. |
2010 |
Affirms multi-reign usage of stamped jars with MMST = Ramat Rahel's estate, not the palace (13 pages) |
Neue Kirchliche Beitschrift vol. 17 |
Die in Palastina Ausgegrabenen Altisraelitischen Krugstempel |
Sellin, D. (Ernst?) |
1906 |
German article that analyzes the major theories & proposes a combination of one by Sayce & one by Macalister--that some names in 1Chronicles 2-4 should be interpreted as places rather than people, that MMST=Mareshah, & that the 4 words represent 4 potteries established by Uzziah (10 pages) |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 1 (A-El), The |
Beth-Shemesh |
Stern, Ephraim & Bunimovitz, Shlomo & Lederman, Zvi |
1993 |
Briefly discusses the stratum LMLK handles were excavated from & provides an H4L photo |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 2 (Em-Je), The |
Hebron |
Stern, Ephraim & Ofer, Avi |
1993 |
Briefly mentions LMLK handles excavated at Tel Hebron & provides an H2D photo |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 3 (Jo-Pel), The |
Judeideh, Tell |
Stern, Ephraim & Broshi, Magen |
1993 |
Briefly mentions LMLK handles excavated at Moresheth-Gath & provides an H4L photo |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 3 (Jo-Pel), The |
Lachish |
Stern, Ephraim & Ussishkin, David |
1993 |
A few succinct summary paragraphs about important conclusions drawn from the major excavations there along with a photo of 3 jars |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 4 (Pet-Z), The |
Qasile, Tell |
Stern, Ephraim & Dothan, Trude & Dunayevsky, Imanuel |
1993 |
Describes the incised LMLK ostracon & includes a photo |
New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land vol. 4 (Pet-Z), The |
Ramat Rahel |
Stern, Ephraim & Aharoni, Yohanan |
1993 |
Briefly mentions LMLK handles excavated at Ramat Rahel & provides a good photo of an H2D & #687-22a personal seal on the same handle |
Nimrud & Its Remains vol. 1 |
|
Mallowan, M.E.L. |
1966 |
Presents a lion weight with a LMLK inscription possibly from Jerusalem (1 page of text & 3 photos) |
Orte und Landschaften der Bibel: ein Handbuch und Studien-Reisefuhrer zum Heiligen Land, Band 2: Der Suden |
|
Keel, Othmar & Kuchler, Max |
1982 |
German handbook that includes a discussion on Tell Goded (H4L drawing) |
Our Work in Palestine |
|
Palestine Exploration Fund
|
1873 |
Mentions "King Zepha" & "King Shat" via Birch, & "crest of an eagle" (3 pages, 2 drawings of the original handles) |
Palastina und Seine Kultur in Funf Jahrtausenden |
|
Thomsen, Peter |
1909 |
German book with a single-page overview explaining MMST as a mystery/riddle, Mampsis perhaps--note that in his 1932 revision of this book published as "Alte Orient vol. 30" he listed Moreseth & Moza instead of MMST (photo of 1 H4L & 2 S2U handles) |
Palastinensische Kleinkunst |
|
Reifenberg, Adolf |
1927 |
German book with a page that speculates one day complete jars may be found to prove/disprove the royal volume theory plus a photocopy of a page of drawings from PEQ vol. 31 |
PEQ vol. 2 |
Phoenician Inscription on Jar Handles |
Warren, Charles |
30 September 1870 |
(click here for complete transcription) |
PEQ vol. 13 |
Some Remarks on the Interpretation of the Impressions on the Vase Handles Found at the Foot of the Temple Wall |
Greene, J. Baker |
October 1881 |
Analyzes the inscriptions in consideration of Molech-worship & proposes that they are compound deity names (i.e., LMLK ZF = "To the Lord (Molech) who watches" (7 pages) |
PEQ vol. 25 |
Cuneiform & Other Inscriptions Found at Lachish & Elsewhere in the South of Palestine, The |
Sayce, A.H. |
January 1893 |
Only one paragraph that mentions similarities between concentric circles on an ivory plaque & a royal Egyptian scarab with those on the LMLK handles; also provides details about 4 of Warren's original handles |
PEQ vol. 25 |
Phoenician Inscriptions on the Vase Handles Found at Jerusalem, The |
Sayce |
July 1893 |
Interprets LMLK --ST as Melech-Sheth, LMLK SUKE as Melech-Shochoh, LMLK ZF as Melech-Ziph & discusses Canaanite & Egyptian deity names (2 pages) |
PEQ vol. 31 |
Second Report on the Excavations at Tell Zakariya |
Bliss, F.J. |
April 1899 |
Interprets the first LMLK HBRN handle as "King of Hebron" & dates them between Caleb's conquest & King Saul (2 pages plus drawing of H4L) |
PEQ vol. 31 |
Third Report on the Excavations at Tell Zakariya |
Bliss, F.J. |
July 1899 |
Discusses 12 handles found at Azekah & interprets their icons & inscriptions in conjunction with the original 6 found at Jerusalem (3 pages plus drawings of 9 impressions) |
PEQ vol. 31 |
Note on the Inscribed Jar-Handle & Weight found at Tell Zakariya |
Clermont-Ganneau, C. |
July 1899 |
Identifies the 2 icons with Egyptian symbols, encourages the city-names theory, establishes the popular reading "To the King.--(city)", & proposes that the jars were related to a military build-up (4 pages plus a paragraph quoting H.V. Hilprecht who proposes dating the seals to the range 300-1 B.C. instead of from Joshua to Saul & identifies the inscriptions with potters) |
PEQ vol. 31 |
Note on the Objects Discovered by Dr. Bliss at Tell Zakariya |
Sayce, A.H. |
July 1899 |
Describes 3 handles (two S2x & one Z2U), reaffirms his geographical name theory but drops his deity theory, & comments on the lack of a definite article in "LMLK" indicating a Phoenician style (about 1 page of relevant content) |
PEQ vol. 32 |
Fourth Report on the Excavations at Tell Zakariya |
Bliss, F.J. |
January 1900 |
Describes 4 handles found at Azekah (1 page plus drawing of Z4CI) |
PEQ vol. 32 |
Age of the Inscribed Jar-Handles from Palestine, The |
Sayce, A.H. |
January 1900 |
Limits the LMLK timeframe based on 4 criteria--a handle with a stamped oval cartouche found at Tell El-Amarna, concentric circles, upward winged icons, & 1Chronicles 4, all of which narrows them to the 8th century (4 pages plus El-Amarna handle photo) |
PEQ vol. 32 |
Second Report on the Excavations at Tell Ej-Judeideh |
Bliss, F.J. |
July 1900 |
Presents a classification system based on 37 handles found at Moresheth-Gath & the first comprehensive analysis of the handles, symbols, inscriptions, & possible dates (13 pages; drawings of 8 impressions) |
PEQ vol. 32 |
List of Casts & Wax Impressions of Stamped Jar-Handles |
Bliss, F.J. |
July 1900 |
A single page with vague descriptions of 5 handles from Moresheth-Gath & 6 from Azekah |
PEQ vol. 32 |
Inscribed Jar-Handles of Palestine |
Clermont-Ganneau |
July 1900 |
Corrects the reading of a handle excavated in 1874 from NB to HBRN (1 page) |
PEQ vol. 33 |
Jar-Handle Inscriptions I |
Wright, Theodore F. |
January 1901 |
Restates the original reports & possible interpretations, notably the icon being associated with the Hebrew 'RB (i.e., scarab; 2 pages) |
PEQ vol. 33 |
Jar-Handle Inscriptions II |
Conder, C.R. |
January 1901 |
Discusses the importance of the discovery of the first clear MMST inscription with the interpretation, "Dedicated to the Moloch who presides over the water that will be drawn (MST) by means of this jar" (1 page) |
PEQ vol. 37 |
Craftsmen's Guild of the Tribe of Judah, The |
Macalister, R.A. Stewart |
July 1905 |
Chapters 1-3 of a detailed & creative interpretation of genealogies in 1Chronicles 4 based on the theory that the LMLK inscriptions represent potters (10 pages) |
PEQ vol. 37 |
Craftsmen's Guild of the Tribe of Judah (Conclusion), The |
Macalister, R.A. Stewart |
October 1905 |
Chapters 4-6 of a detailed & creative interpretation of genealogies in 1Chronicles 4 based on the theory that the LMLK inscriptions represent potters, & concludes that MMST & ZYF impressions date to the apostasy of Joash while the HBRN & SUKE ones date to the reign of Ahaz (14 pages plus full-page genealogy chart) |
PEQ vol. 73 |
On Ancient Hebrew Inscriptions Discovered at Tell Ed-Duweir (Lachish)--II |
Diringer, David & Inge, Charles H. |
July 1941 |
Provides a list/description of all seals found at Lachish up to that time; the P.S. by Inge argues for the "Bath LMLK" theory (20 pages, 2 plates of 31 LMLK impressions, 1 plate of personal seal impressions, & Bath LMLK photo) |
PEQ vol. 80 |
Reviews & Notices: Tell En-Nasbeh |
Tufnell, Olga |
July-October 1948 |
A laudatory review of the McCown/Wampler books with a comparison of seals found at Lachish (3 pages) |
Prophets & Markets: The Political Economy of Ancient Israel |
|
Silver, Morris |
1983 |
Includes the LMLK seals as an example of common practice throughout the ancient world to apply brands or descriptions to stored products (about 7 pages) |
PSBA vol. 20 #155 |
Herodian Pottery & the Siloam Inscription |
Pilcher, E.J. |
June 1898 |
Argues for dating Hezekiah's tunnel inscription & the LMLK seals to King Herod (includes drawings of 4 of the original 6 impressions excavated by Warren along with the first 2 handle illustrations of a Z2D & Plus mark) |
PSBA vol. 32 #238 |
Jewish Royal Pottery Stamps, The |
Pilcher, E.J. |
March 1910 |
Discussion of the 4 major Palestinian strata (using many quotes from Bliss) in an attempt to narrow down the date of LMLK ware (9 pages of text plus photos of a Z4CI & S2U) |
PSBA vol. 32 #239 |
Jewish Royal Pottery Stamps (continued), The |
Pilcher, E.J. |
May 1910 |
Presentation of Persian 2-winged icons to support dating all LMLK seals to Persian rule around 375 BC (9 pages of text; photos of a Z4CI & 3 coins bearing 2-winged icons; drawings of similar, significant 2-winged icons) |
Qadmoniot vol. 9 #2-3 (34-35) |
"Lamelekh" Store-Jars & the Excavation at Lachish |
Ussishkin, D. |
1976 |
Hebrew article (5 pages) with photos of excavated jars in situ, 4 restored jars, & 3 impressions |
Qadmoniot vol. 15 #2-3 (58-59) |
Lachish in the Days of the Kingdom of Judah--The Recent Archaeological Excavations |
Ussishkin, D. |
1982 |
Hebrew article (15 pages) with photos of complete Jar 10091 & its H4L impression |
Qedem: Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology 29 |
Excavations in the South of the Temple Mount: the Ophel of Biblical Jerusalem |
Mazar, Eilat & Mazar, Benjamin & Nadelman, Yonatan |
1989 |
Less than a page of LMLK text with a corpus table, but 1 plate of 19 photos of impressions (& 1 drawing of a handle) & about a page of discussion related to plus marks on small, non-LMLK pot handles (also photos of 12 plus marks & 8 circles-only handles) |
Qedem: Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology 37 |
Timnah (Tel Batash) Final Reports I: Stratigraphy & Architecture |
Mazar, Amihai |
1997 |
A chapter of archaeological text about "The LMLK Jars Building" with several photos showing various rooms as they were being excavated (about 6 pages & 12 photos) |
Qedem: Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology 41 |
Excavations at the City of David 1978-1985 Directed by Yigal Shiloh vol. 6: Inscriptions |
Ariel, Donald T. & Shoham, Yair |
2000 |
Only 1 page of text & a corpus table, but 2 plates of impression photos (17) & drawings (13) & a plate of circle photos (including 2 handles with personal seals & circles) |
Qedem: Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology 42 |
Timnah (Tel Batash) II: The Finds from the First Millennium BCE, Plates |
Mazar, Amihai & Panitz-Cohen, Nava |
2001 |
Companion drawings for the "Text" book of all the jars & handles recovered |
Qedem: Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology 42 |
Timnah (Tel Batash) II: The Finds from the First Millennium BCE, Text |
Mazar, Amihai & Panitz-Cohen, Nava |
2001 |
Comprehensive discussion of all the jars & handles recovered (9 pages of text, 1 jar photo, 12 impression photos) |
Quarterly of the Department of Antiquities in Palestine vol. 14, The |
Citadel, Jerusalem. A Summary of Work Since 1934, The |
Johns, C.N. |
1950 |
Photo of an M2D handle with a brief description of where it was excavated |
Qumran Excavations 1993-2004 Preliminary Report, The |
|
Magen, Yitzhak & Peleg, Yuval |
2007 |
Color photo of an H2D handle with a brief description of where it was excavated |
RB vol. 8 #3 |
Chronique--Notes Archaeologiques et Nouvelles: Les Fouilles Anglaises a Tell Zakariya |
Vincent, H. |
July 1899 |
French article that reviews & rejects the Molok & regional king theories in light of the newly discovered H4L from Azekah (2 pages) |
RB vol. 9 #4 |
Chronique: Les Fouilles Anglaises |
L. (probably Victor Lecoffre) |
October 1900 |
French article that reviews theories by Bliss & Clermont-Ganneau concluding that MMST is not Moresheth-Gath (2 pages) |
RB vol. 10 |
Bulletin |
Lecoffre, V. |
1901 |
French article that belittles the interpretations of Wright & Conder published in English journals earlier in the year (1 page) |
RB vol. 9 |
Chronique: Les Recentes Fouilles d'Ophel |
Vincent, H. |
1912 |
French article presenting an M2T excavated in Jerusalem, which appears to have "MRST" instead of "MMST" prompting the author to identify it with Moresheth (3 pages with 5 detailed drawings of the handle & impression) |
RB vol. 39 #1 |
Melanges: L'Ancien Hebreu dans la Vie Courante |
Dhorme, P. |
January 1930 |
French single-page summary that mentions the first handles found at Nasbeh 6-12-1929 |
RB vol. 79 #3 |
Recension: "Die Konigs-Stempel" par P. Welten |
Lang, Bernhard |
July 1972 |
French review of Welten's book that compliments him for his typology (& demonstrates its usefulness for future publications) & presents his main subjects in a mostly objective manner but points out the difficulty of dating based on paleography (4 pages) |
RB vol. 82 #1 |
MMST=Amwas, Vers la Solution d'Une Enigme de l'Epigraphie Hebraique |
Lemaire, Andre |
January 1975 |
French article presenting evidence to identify MMST with a geographical place midway between Tel Aviv & Jerusalem based on impressions found at northern sites (as opposed to southern sites such as Kurnub) & an analysis of the root-meaning ("overnight lodging place") of the Hebrew consonants (9 pages including a hand-drawn map of the area) |
Recent Discoveries on the Temple Hill at Jerusalem |
|
King, James |
1884 |
Identifies the icon as Baal via Aten & inscriptions as "To King Zepha" & King Shat via Birch, & potter names via Clermont-Ganneau (3 pages, 2 drawings of the original handles) |
Recovery of Jerusalem, The |
|
Chester, Greville J. & Warren, Capt. |
1871 |
Minor additional details beyond the original report (3 pages, 2 drawings--both appear twice in the same book but different chapters) |
Recueil d'Archeologie Orientale, Tome IV |
|
Clermont-Ganneau, Ch. |
1901 |
French book that reiterates & elaborates on his Journal Asiatique ser. 8 vol. 1 & PEQ vol. 31 publications (20 pages plus drawings of Warren's first 2 handles, the first H4L handle, & the 9 stamps published by Bliss in "Third Report on the Excavations at Tell Zakariya") |
Religion in Judah Under the Assyrians, 732-609 BC |
|
McKay, John |
1973 |
Identifies the x2x seals with sun worship during Josiah's reign (1 page plus S4L & x2x drawings) |
Renewed Archaeological Excavations at Lachish (1973-1994) Volume I, The |
|
Ussishkin, David |
2004 |
Contains a detailed overview of work at the site with scattered references to LMLK stamps (color photos of 3 restored jars, 2 H4L stamps, 1 S2U handle) |
Renewed Archaeological Excavations at Lachish (1973-1994) Volume IV, The |
|
Ussishkin, David & Zimhoni, Orna & Barkay, Gabriel & Vaughn, Andrew G. |
2004 |
Section written by Zimhoni = TA vol. 17 #1; section written by Barkay & Vaughn = TA vol. 23 #1 with an exhaustive list of handles excavated prior to Ussishkin's work; section written by Ussishkin lists each handle he excavated, & he states a preference for the designation "private" rather than "official" for the Personal seals (24 pages of text plus tables & charts, photos & drawings of 8 jars [including overhead drawings showing the position of each stamp on each handle], 2 H2U, 2 S2U, 1 x2U, 5 H4L [including 1 with Plus mark], & 3 H4C stamps) |
Repertoire d'Epigraphie Semitique Tome III 1201-2000 |
|
Chabot, J.B. |
1918 |
French book that provides an exhaustive LMLK bibliography from 1871-1910 with a corpus of 87 & general overview under listing #1242, brief mention of the first Gezer M2T--#1243, a Jericho S2DR--#1500, & an Ophel M2T--#1501 (7 pages) |
Restoration Quarterly vol. 28 #1 |
Judean LMLK Stamps: Some Unresolved Issues, The |
Moore, Michael S. |
1985/6 |
Summarizes the early theories surrounding LMLK paleography, correctly predicting that Ussishkin's Lachish excavations would resolve many of them; also correctly (& humorously) labels the geographical name theories as "weak", "weaker", & "weakest" (about 9 pages) |
Retrieving the Past |
Hurvat Shilhah: An Iron Age Site in the Judean Desert |
Seger, Joe D. & Mazar, Amihai |
1996 |
Article summarizing evidence for 7th-century use of 8th-century jars (photo of Z2D handle) |
Revue Archeologique ser. 4, vol. 12 |
Poids Bilingue Provenant de Palestine |
Dussaud, Rene |
July-December 1908 |
French article that compares plaque-weights with "Palace of the king of Assyria--1 Mina of the King" written in Assyrian cuneiform & "MNE MLK" in Aramean Paleo-Hebrew to LMLK seals as royal measures established after conquering Judah (6 pages; photos of 1 H4L & 2 S2U handles & lion-shaped plaque) |
Royal Functionaries & State-Administration in Israel & Judah During the First Temple Period |
|
Fox, Nili S. |
1997 |
A dissertation with a well-written, comprehensive chapter fairly summarizing all LMLK research that presents a slightly different theory of personal seals belonging to recipients of land grants (31 pages in double-spaced format) |
Samaria in Ahab's Time: Harvard Excavations & Their Results |
|
Jack, J.W. |
1929 |
Brief overview in light of the Samaria Ostraca (3 pages) |
Scripta Hierosolymitana vol. 8 |
Ancient Judaean Weights & the Date of the Samaria Ostraca |
Rabin, Chaim & Yadin, Yigael |
1961 |
Article by Yadin that presents data to support the interpretation of a symbol on shekel weights to be a stylized version of the 4-winged icon on LMLK seals (6 pages & photo of famous Lachish M4L) |
Scripture & Other Artifacts |
Hezekiah's Reform & the Altars at Beer-sheba & Arad |
Rainey, Anson F. & Greene, Joseph A. |
1994 |
A chapter that includes a brief discussion of the Beersheba LMLK pithos jar |
Scripture & Other Artifacts |
Northern Shephelah in the Iron Age: Some Issues in Biblical History & Archaeology, The |
Mazar, Amihai & Greene, Joseph A. |
1994 |
A chapter that includes a 2-page discussion of LMLK jars found at Timnah & Gezer |
Sefer Hebron ("CFR HBRUN" in Hebrew) |
|
Avissar, Oded |
1970 |
Hebrew book with H4L drawing on cover & H4L handle photo with brief text. |
Shlomo: Studies in the Epigraphy, Iconography, History & Archaeology in Honor of Shlomo Moussaieff |
Hoard of Fifty Hebrew Clay Bullae from the Time of Hezekiah in the Shlomo Moussaieff Collection, A |
Deutsch, Robert |
2003 |
Includes photos of a Maon LMLK bulla, 3 bullae from King Hezekiah's personal seals, & several bullae made by seals of King Hezekiah's servants |
Short Guide to the Excavations of Ramat Rahel |
|
anonymous (probably Yohanan Aharoni) |
1955 |
One paragraph describing the icon as a flying scroll, & 1 photo of a Z2D handle |
Solomonic State Officials |
|
Mettinger, Tryggve N.D. |
1971 |
Makes much use of Welten's "Die Konigs-Stempel" to argue against the royal capacity theory, & argue for the royal estates to military garrison delivery theory (4 pages) |
Studies in the Iconography of Northwest Semitic Inscribed Seals |
Propos des Sceaux Ouest-Semitiques: Le Role de l'Iconographie dans l'Attribution d'un Sceau a Une Aire Culturelle ou a un Atelier, A |
Sass, Benjamin & Uehlinger, Christoph & Parayre, Dominique |
1993 |
French article with one generic drawing of an x2U from Lachish but 64 other drawings of similar 2-winged disc icons |
Studies in the Iconography of Northwest Semitic Inscribed Seals |
Pre-Exilic Hebrew Seals: Iconism vs. Aniconism |
Sass, Benjamin & Uehlinger, Christoph |
1993 |
About a page of text discussing the LMLK icons with drawings of an H4L & M2U (same as Naveh, 1982) |
Studies in the Iron Age Pottery of Israel |
|
Zimhoni, Orna |
1997 |
Contains the same excellent content as TA vol. 17 #1--a comprehensive, 50-page study of pottery--mostly storage jars--that can be associated with the most significant Assyrian & Babylonian attacks; only about 2 pages of specific LMLK content (drawings of 3 jars & a photo of Jar 10616) but also an interesting page about lids/stoppers |
Survey of Western Palestine: Jerusalem, The |
Excavations Round the Noble Sanctuary, 1867-1870 |
Warren, Charles |
1884 |
Minor additional details beyond the original report (2 pages, 2 drawings) |
Survey of Western Palestine: Jerusalem, The |
On the Pottery & Glass Found in the Excavations |
Chester, Greville & Warren, Charles & Conder, Claude Reignier |
1884 |
Minor additional details beyond the original report (1 page, 2 drawings) |
Syria vol. 6 |
Samarie Au Temps d'Achab |
Dussaud, Rene |
1925 |
French article that mentions Judean seals relative to the Gezer tablet, Samarian ostraca, & Siloam inscription (2 pages plus paleography table; photos of 2 H4L, 1 M2U, 1 S4L, 2 S2U handles from the PEF) |
TA vol. 1 #1 |
Khirbet Rabud = Debir |
Kochavi, Moshe |
1974 |
Only one sentence with a photo of an M4L |
TA vol. 2 #4 |
Excavations at Tel Beer-Sheba: Preliminary Report of the 5th & 6th Seasons, 1973-1974 |
Aharoni, Yohanan |
1975 |
Photo, line drawing, & 1-page discussion of the Half LMLK Jar |
TA vol. 4 #1-2 |
Destruction of Lachish by Sennacherib & the Dating of the Royal Judean Storage Jars, The |
Ussishkin, David |
1977 |
Contains about 22 well-written pages clarifying the history of excavation at Lachish (plus 6 layout drawings) & 4 more pages of text outlining LMLK chronology theories |
TA vol. 5 #1-2 |
Excavations at Tel Lachish 1973-1977: Preliminary Report |
Ussishkin, David |
1978 |
Contains about 3 pages of text, 2 pages of drawings & matching plates showing 4 complete jars & a sample of each of their LMLK impressions, & a photo of excavated jars in situ |
TA vol. 10 #2 |
Excavations at Tel Lachish 1978-1983: Second Preliminary Report |
Ussishkin, David |
1983 |
A comprehensive article covering all areas of excavation (including radiocarbon dating of wood samples from each stratum) with 2 pages of text discussing restored LMLK jars, a plus mark handle, & a multi-stamp handle (drawings/photos of jars & photos of 4 handles) |
TA vol. 17 #1 |
Two Ceramic Assemblages from Lachish Levels III & II |
Zimhoni, Orna |
1990 |
A comprehensive, 50-page study of pottery--mostly storage jars--that can be associated with the most significant Assyrian & Babylonian attacks; only about 2 pages of specific LMLK content (drawings of 3 jars & a photo of Jar 10616) but also an interesting page about lids/stoppers |
TA vol. 18 #1 |
Kingdom of Judah Under Josiah, The |
Na'aman, Nadav |
1991 |
Compares the distribution of the LMLK & rosette jars with Biblical place-name lists (about 4 pages with an excellent map of excavation sites) |
TA vol. 23 #1 |
LMLK & Official Seal Impressions from Tel Lachish |
Barkay, Gabriel & Vaughn, Andrew G. |
1996 |
A definitive census of Lachish jar handles (13 pages) |
TA vol. 37 #1 |
Royal Judahite Jar Handles: Reconsidering the Chronology of the lmlk Stamp Impressions |
Lipschits, Oded & Sergi, Omer & Koch, Ido |
June 2010 |
Proposed chronological division based on seal types (26 pages & a figure showing 19 seal drawings) |
TA vol. 38 #1 |
Judahite Stamped and Incised Jar Handles: A Tool for Studying the History of Late Monarchic Judah |
Lipschits, Oded & Sergi, Omer & Koch, Ido |
June 2011 |
Elaborates on chronological divisions between early/late LMLKs, Circles, Rosettes (31 pages, 4 distribution maps, 3 corpus tables) |
TA vol. 38 #2 |
Dating of the lmlk Storage Jars and Its Implications: Rejoinder to Lipschits, Sergi and Koch; The |
Ussishkin, David |
November 2011 |
Reaffirms his belief that all LMLK types date to the period shortly before Sennacherib's invasion of Judah (21 pages & 1 Lachish M2D with Circles photo) |
Tell en-Nasbeh vol. 1: Archaeological & Historical Results |
|
McCown, Chester Charlton & Wampler, Joseph Carson |
1947 |
Contains a 5-page section about LMLK handles excavated including a paleography chart, a locus map, a corpus (mainly quoting Diringer's work), & scattered references on at least 11 other pages describing specific locations where the handles were found along with plates of 14 impressions, 3 handles, & the complete Jar 396 |
Tell en-Nasbeh vol. 2: The Pottery |
|
Wampler, Joseph Carson |
1947 |
Contains brief references to LMLK handles & detailed descriptions of the complete Jar 396 |
Textbook of Syrian Semitic Inscriptions vol. 1: Hebrew & Moabite Inscriptions |
|
Gibson, John C.L. |
1971 |
A 3-page general discussion with a vague typology listing |
Textbook of Syrian Semitic Inscriptions vol. 2: Aramaic Inscriptions |
|
Gibson, John C.L. |
1975 |
No text; only line drawings of an H4C, H4L, & H2U to illustrate Diringer's 3 classes |
Theology, History, & Archaeology in the Chronicler's Account of Hezekiah |
|
Vaughn, Andrew G. |
1999 |
The single document with the most up-to-date information about LMLK jar handles |
Thirty Years' Work in the Holy Land |
|
Besant, Walter |
1895 |
Expanded edition of "Twenty Years' Work in the Holy Land" with same drawings of the 2 original handles |
Timnah: A Biblical City in the Sorek Valley |
|
Kelm, George L. & Mazar, Amihai |
1995 |
Describes the handles & jars found at Tel Batash & argues for the military build-up theory (3 pages plus color photos of Jar 7202-2 & M2U & x4L handles) |
Twenty-One Years' Work in the Holy Land |
|
Palestine Exploration Fund & Besant, Walter |
1886 |
Drawings of the 2 original handles (shown upside-down) & says their Phoenician characters are variously interpreted |
Underground Jerusalem: An Account of Some of the Principal Difficulties Encountered in Its Exploration & the Results Obtained |
|
Warren, Charles |
1876 |
Less than a page of remarks surrounding the first handles with 2 drawings |
Underground Jerusalem: Discoveries on the Hill of Ophel (1909-11) |
|
Vincent, H. |
1911 |
Published in French & English, this book includes a paragraph that interprets an M2T seal as Moresheth (drawings of the complete handle & impression) |
Upon This Rock |
|
Zola Levitt Ministries & Barkay, Gabriel |
2002 |
1-hour video with a few minutes of Gabriel Barkay at the Kidron Valley dumps of Temple Mount debris, where he mentions Warren's pioneering excavations & shows the original handle drawings |
VT vol. 11 #3 |
Villes de Juda au Temps d'Ozias, Les |
Feuillet, R. |
July 1961 |
French article that sees paleographic evidence to date the x4C seals to Uzziah's reign & uses the Qumran "2 Seah 7 Log" jar to support the Royal Potteries theory (4 pages plus Diringer's 1949 paleography chart) |
VT vol. 25 #3 |
Remarques sur la Datation des Estampilles "LMLK" |
Lemaire, Andre |
July 1975 |
French article that points out the paleographic significance of the last letter of SUKE in the S4L seals, which allows Diringer's Class II to co-exist (if not predate) Class I to as early as Uzziah's reign in the middle of the 8th century BC |
VT vol. 29 #1 |
Sennacherib's Campaign to Judah & the Date of the LMLK Stamps |
Na'aman, N. |
January 1979 |
Presents solid, logical evidence for positively dating all LMLK impressions to King Hezekiah's reign instead of King Josiah's (26 pages) |
Windows to the Past |
|
Deutsch, Robert & Heltzer, Michael |
1997 |
Presents the incised LMLK oil jar (2 pages of text plus a photo & line drawing) |
Winery, Defenses, & Soundings at Gibeon |
|
Pritchard, James B. |
1964 |
Contains photos of an H2D, G2T, & S4L with a brief description of where they were found |
Writing (vol. 25 in the "Ancient Peoples & Places" series edited by Glyn Daniel) |
|
Diringer, David |
1962 |
No significant text; H4L drawing & Lachish H4C & H2U impression photos |
ZDPV vol. 66 #2 |
Palastinischen Krughenkel mit den Konigsstempeln, Die |
Sellin, Ernst |
1943 |
German article that interprets the inscriptions as "Property of the King", elaborates on the royal estates theory, & dates them from the end of Manasseh to the Babylonian conquest (17 pages) |
ZDPV vol. 91 #1 |
Hirbet Kefire - eine Oberflachenuntersuchung |
Vriezen, Karel J. H. |
1975 |
German article presenting the excavation of Biblical Chephirah (1 page of text plus an x2x photo) |
ZDPV vol. 118 #2 |
Temptation to Identify: Jerusalem, MMST, & the LMLK Jar Stamps |
Kletter, Raz |
2002 |
Reviews the reasons for locating MMST near Hebron & proposes 2 phases of usage (one pre-revolt & one post-revolt) but then gives 5 arguments against it (10 pages including 2 maps) |